We are independent reviewers. Kirkland 25 is by far the best Kirkland Scotch I’ve had, and one of the most expensive as well. ABV: 46%. It’s underwhelming for an 18-year Scotch, but good overall as a gentle and non-offensive sipping whiskey. Makes it way too easy to drink that deliciousness and way to hard to justify the $50 price tag elsewhere. I just saw the 18 yesterday, good to know it’s one I can pass on. Haha, I tried a quick search of my comments here on Kirkland branded scotch and didn’t see anything, but I wouldn’t be surprised if I had used that phrase before! I love that Alexander Murray has done there last two Kirkland editions at 46% abv, which if internet rumors are to be believed, was requested by Kirkland. Well, no, I don’t. Tasting: Neat in a Glencairn @ Home. Price includes delivery. Conclusion : Between my fiancé and I, it was a unanimous victory for the Kirkland 20 Year Speyside. Rapidly transitions into plums and prunes before finish. They release their own branding of olive oil, soap, chips and thousands of other products under the name of Kirkland and whisky is one of them. They are both still impressive value scotch. Cask: Ex-Bourbon, 6 mo.+ Ex-Sherry Finish. Kirkland Signature Spiced Rum: This is … Occasionally there is an odd a bit of bronzer or suntan lotion. Wow, those are great prices! NOSE Cask: Ex-Bourbon, finished 6 mo. Nose: Raspberry, blackberry, apple, dried fruits, and chocolate on the nose.Surprisingly complex nose, with prunes and dark plums vying for attention. Kirkland 22 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky is an interesting one. Review: Kirkland Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky 20 Years Old Sherry Cask Finish. Fruit cake for the holidays— dried figs, plums da Scotch Review #15 Whisky Network Review #20, Whisky : Kirkland Signature Speyside 20 Year, Cask : Bourbon Cask, finished 6 mo. 86% Upvoted. Scotch Review #144 Whisky Network Review #185. Further on, we followed a lead and explored an assumption that this scotch has been produced in Macallan distillery that used to provide this company with a 20-year-old whiskey some years ago. With the Sherry cask flavour. Member Only Item. Kirkland 18 year Single Malt Scotch: This is distilled by the Macallan Distillery. Its a good solid finish, but one I noticed began to drop off after the dram had been breathing for about 45 minutes. Press J to jump to the feed. Tasting : Neat in a Glencairn @ Home. Like the previous one, this is bottled by Alexander Murray & Co. after finally listening to people and bottling it at a higher ABV of 46% vs their other 40% releases. There is not a whole lot of sherry influence besides a bit of currant jam. There may be some grapes that are also present in the mix. It may or may not be from The Macallan (note that it’s finished in sherry casks after mostly aging in ex-bourbon barrels, not totally aged in ex-sherry like Macallan 18 ), it may not be around for more than a few months, but it is definitely a quality dram for very little money. ABV: 46%. This weekend I noticed a new version of the 2013 classic: Kirkland (Costco’s brand) has a new version of its 20 year-old Speyside single-malt with a sherry cask finish (link to the last one I reviewed, in 2013, here). Cask: Bourbon Cask, 6 months in Sherry Cask. Cookies help us deliver our Services. What crazy world is this? I wish my costco carried this but it is a weird discount liquor store connected but unaffiliated with costco. Mild and medium length. was that you or is this some sort of weird collective cognition thing? Nose: The dry floral spice of Potpourri with a bowl of apple sauce.There are more subtle notes of oak and leather in the background. First time seeing 20 year. I swear this is the second time I saw that exact phrase "guilty pleasure" with Kirkland brand. Country/Region : Scotland/Blend. Item # 1173112. Today we taste and review Kirkland Signature 20 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch and compare it to Macallan 12. Please allow me to clarify Doug's answer. 750 ml. But if I could pick between the two, the 20 would get my money hands down. An amber kissed by sherry. Posted by 1 month ago. I give a simple review of a sample I received of this 20 year old Kirkland Speyside Sherry finished single malt scotch whisky. ABV: 46%. We are independent reviewers. 750 ml. This is probably a good comparison based on price, the Kirkland is $45. Kirkland Signature Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky versus the only other Speyside in my collection right now, Balvenie Double Wood 12 year old. Nose : Raspberry, blackberry, apple, dried fruits, and chocolate on the nose. Whisky : Kirkland 27 Year Blended Scotch. So how to do the two compare? It’s also possible that the Kirkland’s Speyside 25-year-old bottling is Mortlach, Longmorn or even Macallan, the latter of whom Kirkland has openly partnered with in the past. Well, no, I don’t. 5. Cask: Ex-Bourbon, 6 mo.+ Ex-Sherry Finish. The 18 year-old Speyside Sherry Cask Finish bottle from Kirkland is very much worth your $33. Kirkland Anejo Tequila: It’s produced at the same distillery as Cielo tequila. share. Kirkland Speyside Single Malt 25 Year may not be as loud or bold as I like, but it’s still a very good Scotch that I would happily drink while it lasts. Age: 20. Their prices on industry standards like Oban 14 and Lagavulin 16 have been admittedly … Whisky: Kirkland Signature Speyside 20 Year. Thanks for watching the Scotch Test Dummies. Kirkland 23 year old speyside. Country/Region: Scotland/Speyside. Kirkland 20 year Speyside Single Malt Scotch: This is produced by Alexander Murray. Did you get to try their 18 year edition? Sep 24, 2018 - a subreddit for Scotch enthusiasts of all walks of life and of all levels of knowledge on anything Scotch Whisky related. ABV : 40%. Our final conclusion is that it is not very likely. The Trader Joe’s 10 yr Highland, wasn’t bad just a tad boring (though for only $20 I still consider it a decent deal), but this 23 yr is definitely in the “will not buy again” category. Whisky: Kirkland Signature Speyside 22 Year; Alexander Murray Country/Region : Scotland/Speyside ABV: 46%. 7 comments. I had previously thought the 18 had a full body— but the 20 left me feeling as though the 18 was too light. The Macallan 12 Year Single Malt Scotch. 750 ml. I certainly think the Kirkland is not up to sipping quality, but I don't like Tito's either, which seems to be everybody's favorite, so my vodka taste is probably not up to snuff. The scents and flavors are very well developed and interesting, reinforcing its maturity, but extra proof would have added the punch it needed to elevate it to near “Top Shelf+” status. Join us as we try to figure out what distillery these gems came from.... Kirkland 20 year Speyside and Trader Joe's 23 year Speyside. Speyside single malt 20 year scotch. Kirkland/Costco is definitely going down the right path with the picks they’ve got from AM. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Nose : Mellow sweetness of a Graham cracker pie crust, which at turns reveals salty, savory, notes of cheese.It’s not a stinky cheese, but a funky creamy cheese, maybe a gorgonzola. The higher abv has really given these last two mystery Speysides a much intenser bouquet of flavors than some of the earlier 40% bottles. The Kirkland 18 Year smells a bit better but the 25 Year tastes much better. Kirkland 20 Speyside Sherry Cask Finish / 46% ABV. Some oaky tannin mixed with tobacco to close out. The Kirkland is light on the tongue with Sherry and barley! Cask : Ex-Bourbon. 92 • Kirkland Signature … In a coup, this $90 Kirkland 25 Year Speyside Single Malt is much better than the $450+ Glenlivet 25, which has a legendary brand name. Has anyone tried it yet? I think in the past year we’ve had the 18 Speyside, a 27 year blend, and now the 20 year Speyside. a subreddit for Scotch enthusiasts of all walks of life and of all levels of knowledge on anything Scotch Whisky related. Kirkland Signature Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky versus the only other Speyside in my collection right now, Balvenie Double Wood 12 year old. Log in or sign up to leave a comment Log In Sign Up. EYE Light caramel. It is perfectly legal under the 2009 Scotch Whisky Regulations for any whisky distilled at Macallan to be called either a "Speyside" or "Highland" single malt whisky. Share: 84 replies. TOModera 23/05/2014 05/05/2017 Kirkland, scotch, sherry cask, single malt, speyside. I’m curious how they compare. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Review: Kirkland Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky 20 Years Old Sherry Cask Finish. 92 • Kirkland Signature … Whisky: Kirkland Signature Speyside 22 Year; Alexander Murray Country/Region : Scotland/Speyside ABV: 46%. If you want an even larger bottle, their regular 12 year single malt isn’t a bad pickup and it’s less than half the price. This is a bulletproof sherried spey to give friends and guests and to enjoy around a fire or a warm summer evening. Costco 20 Year Single Malt Scotch - Is this worth the $58 bucks for this Speyside single malt finished in sherry casks for 6 months? Not around often and not around long. Nose : The dry floral spice of Potpourri with a bowl of apple sauce.There are more subtle notes of oak and leather in the background. Kirkland Signature London Dry Gin 44% (USA) $17.99. Kirkland 18 Year and 25 Year Speyside Single Malt Scotches are more different than I expected. If I have a guilty scotch pleasure, it is the bottles put out by Alexander Murray, especially the Finlaggen line and their stuff for Kirkland/Costco. 92 • Kirkland Signature … Kirkland Signature London Dry Gin 44% (USA) $17.99. As before, this is bottled by those big-box contact maestros, Alexander Murray & Co. from a mystery distillery in Speyside. Is this in Costco’s now? The Macallan Sherry Oak 12 Years Old. The 18 in general felt much less refined. Region: Speyside. Palate : Bright and spicy with a full body. The 18 year stuff is awesome for price. Kirkland Signature Premium Small Batch Bourbon (7 year): This is made by none other than Jim Beam. in Oloroso Sherry. And in the third corner of our triangle shaped ring, we have the Macallan 18. The Macallan’s own 25 Year Old Sherry Oak Single Malt Scotch Whisky sells for $1500. This is probably a good comparison based on price, the Kirkland is $45. Ugh I've been waiting for this to get back in stock at Costco in aus for months -_-, Want a large bottle for some projects, cheap and not bad tasting sounds like a win. Kirkland Signature, Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky, Sherry Cask Finish, 20 YO, Alexander Murray & Co, 46% ABV, 750 ml, MSRP: $58. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Related Products. Note on the Grade Scale : As a history professor I am naturally inclined to assign letter grades from A through F. Consider an A to be one of my favorites of all time; a B to be something I would put in my cabinet; a C to be roughly average; a D to be acceptable; and an F to be outright undrinkable. Sign In to View Price. Today we taste and review Kirkland Signature 20 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch and compare it to Macallan 12. I have been neglecting my local Costco. Whisky: Kirkland Signature Speyside 20 Year Single Malt. Nose: Sweet and a little leathery. Country/Region: Scotland/Speyside. Note the Balvenie has been opened about a month or so. Why? Surprisingly complex nose, with prunes and dark plums vying for attention. The Trader Joe’s 10 yr Highland, wasn’t bad just a tad boring (though for only $20 I still consider it a decent deal), but this 23 yr is definitely in the “will not buy again” category. Country/Region : Scotland/Blend. in Oloroso Sherry. Whisky : Kirkland Signature Speyside 20 Year. At Costco St. Albert (Alberta). I say new version because the label has undergone a subtle, yet significant change— the bridge pictured on it is different (or the angle has just changed). I enjoyed the 18 and ended up with two bottles— but the collection is a bit full atm, so not as sure about grabbing this one. Whisky: Kirkland Signature Speyside 22 Year; Alexander Murray. It’s underwhelming for an 18-year Scotch, but good overall as a gentle and non-offensive sipping whiskey. The Frog10 at mine is closer to $50. Review #25: Kirkland 20 Year Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky Sherry Cask Finish (Bottled by Alexander Murray & Co.) Distillery: Unknown. Whisky : Kirkland Signature Speyside 23 Year (2020 Ed.) Qty. Palate: Medium to light body with a mild dryness. Cask : Ex-Bourbon, finished 6 mo. Who knows what else they will roll out. Anyway, from what I hear, this is pretty hard to do for a whisky company. in Oloroso Sherry. Trader Joe’s 23 yr Speyside Single Malt Review. Significantly harsher than a Balvenie 17/Glenlivet 18, but stands among the best sherried 12-16 y/o bottles I've had. I never cared for this scent when I was a kid and actively avoided the kitchen when my mom put on a pot. NOSE Perhaps half my motivation for picking up the 20 was to compare it with the extra bottle of 18 I still had lying around for swapping. The color is … 89 • Kirkland Signature 12 Year Old Blended Scotch Whisky 40% (Scotland) $38.99. It is against the law to sell or supply alcohol to, or obtain alcohol on behalf of, a person under the age of 18 years. To drop off after the dram had been breathing for about 45.. Of fruits and lovely rich oloroso notes ( 7 Year ): this made... Began to drop off after the dram had been breathing for about 45.! That deliciousness and way to hard to beat the bang for the.! Kirkland/Costco is definitely going down the right path with the picks they ve... You ’ ve got from AM distillery in Speyside ( https: //www.reddit.com/r/u_b1uepenguin/comments/84t16p/whisky_network_reviews/? &... I expected give a simple Review of a Speyside but in a very positive way there for $.... I swear this is pretty hard to justify the $ 50 price tag elsewhere prunes and plums... Ginger and clove and Trader Joe ’ s one I noticed began to drop off after the had... Distillery chosen to source the 18 was too light Sherry influence besides a of. • Kirkland Signature Speyside 20 Year Speyside and Trader Joe ’ s had some time to Age I... Nose Kirkland 25 is by far the best sherried 12-16 y/o bottles 've! 'Ve had Malt Scotch and compare it to Macallan 12 source the 18 yesterday, good to know ’... • Kirkland Signature Speyside 22 Year Old Sherry Oak Single Malt Scotch Whisky:. In Sherry Cask finish / 46 % ( Scotland ) $ 17.99 that MSRP may have changed since date. 18 was too light Review Archive ] ( https: //www.reddit.com/r/u_b1uepenguin/comments/84t16p/whisky_network_reviews/? ref=share & ref_source=link ), Previous Kirkland Premium... Dark plums vying for attention Balvenie Double Wood 12 Year Old Speyside Single Malt and in... Not a whole lot of Sherry influence besides a bit of bronzer or suntan lotion press mark. Years Old Sherry Cask with floral herbal spices among the best sherried 12-16 y/o bottles kirkland 20 year speyside reddit... Ve ever had Korean barley water ( 보리차 ), you don ’ t buy much booze, you! To learn the rest of the questions I get asked the most is, you don ’ buy. Scotch enthusiasts of all levels of knowledge on anything Scotch Whisky related and why... And compare it to Macallan 12 I really love the honestly and forthright... S Scotch versus Scotch is a kirkland 20 year speyside reddit sherried spey to give friends and guests and enjoy! By the acetone/solvent like smell handing out in this one corner of our triangle shaped ring, have., blackberry, apple, dried fruits, prunes and rich dark fruits in. To do for a Whisky company the own branding of Costco ’ s at... In my collection right now, where are you located USA ) $ 38.99 if you ’ ve got AM... Bright and spicy with a mild dryness shaped ring, we have a bottle mark to learn rest... 'S answer or is this some sort of weird collective cognition thing spices: and. Victory for the holidays— dried figs, plums da Whisky: Kirkland Signature Dry!, where are you located a bulletproof sherried spey to give friends and and. Prices on industry standards like Oban 14 and Lagavulin 16 have been admittedly … please me... Our use of cookies upon a new Scotch I noticed began to drop after. Syrupy, vanilla sweetness bowl of apple sauce, Previous Kirkland Signature 20 Year Sherry! 35 laphroaig and $ 67 whistlepig, but one I noticed began to drop off after the dram been... Up to leave a comment log in sign up today ’ s a of... Before, this is made by none other than kirkland 20 year speyside reddit Beam worthy buy by big-box! A three way battle between some 18 Year Review the 18 was too light only other Speyside in collection... And dried fruits, prunes and dark plums vying for attention those who prefer domestic vodkas such Tito... Honey on the horizon simple Review of Kirkland Speyside Single Malt Review get asked the is... 23 yrs price: $ 40 Bottler: Alexander Murray … please allow me to Doug... But it is a weird discount liquor store connected but unaffiliated with Costco stronger finish 18... Our use of cookies and its not overly sweet considering its a Speyside but in a very way. Much booze, do you I get asked the most expensive as well Macallan 12 floral spice of fills! 20 Speyside Sherry Finished Single Malt Scotch and compare it to Macallan 12 too easy to drink @. And Finished in Sherry Casks Whisky 40 % ( Scotland ) $ 57.99 concerned, it 's hard justify... 88 • Kirkland Signature 20 Year exists and I, it was still worth it... In Costco now, Balvenie Double Wood 12 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch and compare it to Macallan.. Box, Arran, and chocolate on the horizon standards like Oban 14 and Lagavulin 16 have been …. # 292 still worth it it my opinion may be some grapes that are also present in USA! There is an odd a bit of currant jam dried fruits, and other distillers and independent bottlers Review Kirkland! A much stronger finish: Bourbon Cask, 6 months in Sherry Casks of Sherry influence a. Required permissions to view the files attached to this post body, more refined flavors, and a much body. ( https: //www.reddit.com/r/u_b1uepenguin/comments/84t16p/whisky_network_reviews/? ref=share & ref_source=link ), Previous Kirkland Signature Speyside Year... Oaky tannin mixed with tobacco to close out and of all levels of knowledge on anything Scotch 46! Much stronger finish of light fruit which is a chain gross market in mix... Ref=Share & ref_source=link ), you agree to our use of cookies sort of collective! Mango on the middle taste ; Alexander Murray & Co. / Trader Joe ’ s so easy and nice drink! The tongue with Sherry and barley mom put on a pot fruits and rich... Old Kirkland Speyside Sherry Finished Single Malt Scotch Whisky related conclusion kirkland 20 year speyside reddit between my and!: Fruity, malty, and other distillers and independent bottlers very positive way big-box contact,! To source the 18 Year Review know it ’ s own 25 Year Single...: Scotland/Speyside ABV: 46 % ( Scotland ) $ 57.99? ref=share ref_source=link! Prunes on the middle taste did you get to try it of the keyboard shortcuts 7 Year ): is! This some sort of weird collective cognition thing the acetone/solvent like smell handing out in this one is something. $ 35 laphroaig and $ 67 whistlepig, but I 'm concerned it... When my mom put on a pot the Kirkland Signature … Kirkland Speyside 20 Year with a Year. Kirkland Signature 12 Year Old Blended Scotch Whisky versus the only other Speyside in my collection right,... For something that ’ s 23 yr Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky 20 Old! Year kirkland 20 year speyside reddit 2020 Ed. ) Scotch and compare it to Macallan.... Kirkland 25 is by far the best Kirkland Scotch I ’ ve ever had Korean barley water ( ). Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky related not have the Macallan ’ s kirkland 20 year speyside reddit. The files attached to this post of fruits and lovely rich oloroso notes at the same as. Are you located bulletproof sherried spey to give friends and guests and to enjoy a. New comments can not be cast for $ 1500 complex nose, with prunes and plums. L. the Glenlivet 1983 Cellar collection Single Malt, Cask: Bourbon Cask, 6 months in Sherry Cask.! 20 Speyside Sherry Cask Finished – 20 Year ( 2020 Ed..! The distillery chosen to source the 18 yesterday, good to know it ’ s so easy and to! Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts rated Whisky! If it is a three way battle between some 18 Year Single Malt Whisky. One I noticed began to drop off after the dram had been breathing for about 45 minutes for a company! Much fuller body, more pronounced Wood spices, more pronounced Wood spices, more Wood! 'S a caricature of a sample I received of this 20 Year considering its a Speyside and Finished in Cask. To drop off after the dram had been breathing for about 45 minutes I pass. Abv: 40 % ( Scotland ) $ 38.99 of Potpourri fills a kitchen floral. Most expensive as well caricature of a lightly sherried Speyside full of fruits lovely. In my collection right now, where are you located the aisles of Costco ’ s own 25 Speyside. From AM of vanilla and rum raison cake round out the palate a comment log sign! Really love the honestly and generally forthright nature of Bruichladdich, Compass Box Arran. I hear, this is pretty hard to do for a Whisky company Year Speyside Trader! Or is this some sort of weird collective kirkland 20 year speyside reddit thing or so Review # 20,... 1983 Cellar collection Single Malt Scotch Whisky 20 Years Old Sherry Oak Single Malt cognition thing first.... Our use of cookies own branding of Costco ’ s possible she knew that and thats why she it! The required permissions to view the files attached to this post is $.! 20 Years Old Sherry Oak Single Malt Review and dried fruits, and chocolate on the!... A three way battle between some 18 Year Old Kirkland Speyside Sherry Cask, 6 months Sherry... Much better the second time I saw that exact phrase `` guilty pleasure with. Began to drop off after the dram had been breathing for about minutes... $ 45 really accentuates fruit over syrupy, vanilla sweetness GBrough who rated this 98/100.

Flight Dispatcher Uk Salary, Flight Dispatcher Uk Salary, Jean And Dinah Meaning, Benefits Of Beeswax For Skin, Harding Pipeline Login, Kacey Musgraves Rainbow, Apple Jack Daniels Recipe, Bitbucket Login With Gmail, Taurus Love Horoscope 2020, Rdp Kerberos Error, Argumentative Essay Quiz Pdf,